Differentiation of Settle plates Vs Contact Plates

This article contains Differentiation between Settle plates Vs Contact Plates

Differentiation between settle plates Vs Contact Plates

Settle plates and contact plates are both used in microbiology for environmental monitoring and microbial contamination assessment, but they have different purposes and methods of use. Settle plates are designed for assessing airborne microbial contamination, while contact plates are used to sample microorganisms from surfaces. The choice between the two depends on the specific microbiological assessment needed in a given environment or situation.

Purpose:

• Settle Plates: Settle plates are primarily used to assess the microbial contamination of the air in a specific location. They are placed in an area of interest, and microorganisms settle onto the agar surface over a period of time.
• Contact Plates: Contact plates, on the other hand, are used to assess microbial contamination on surfaces. They are pressed or “contacted” directly onto a surface of interest to sample microorganisms present on that surface.

Sampling Method:

• Settle Plates: Settle plates rely on passive sampling. They are left open to the air for a specified duration, typically 4 hours, during which airborne microorganisms settle onto the agar surface due to gravity.
• Contact Plates: Contact plates use an active sampling method. A person presses the agar surface of the contact plate against a specific surface, allowing microorganisms to transfer from the surface to the agar medium.

Location:

Settle plates Vs Contact Plates :

• Settle Plates: Settle plates are typically placed in an elevated position within a cleanroom or controlled environment to capture airborne microorganisms.
• Contact Plates: Contact plates are placed directly on surfaces that need to be sampled, such as countertops, equipment, Garments or other surfaces of interest.

Application:

Settle plates Vs Contact Plates:

• Settle Plates: They are used to monitor the air quality and the level of airborne microbial contamination in environments like cleanrooms, pharmaceutical manufacturing areas, or hospitals.
• Contact Plates: Contact plates are used to assess the cleanliness and microbial contamination on surfaces, making them useful for hygiene monitoring and validation of cleaning procedures in various industries like pharmaceutical, Food and its laboratories too.

Exposure Time:

• Settle Plates: Settle plates are typically exposed to the air for an extended period, often 4 hours, to capture a sufficient number of microorganisms.
• Contact Plates: Contact plates are pressed onto surfaces for a shorter duration, usually a few seconds to a minute, to sample surface microorganisms.

Portability:

Settle plates Vs Contact Plates :

• Settle Plates: Settle plates are relatively stationary and are typically placed in strategic locations within a controlled environment.
• Contact Plates: Contact plates are more portable and can be carried to different surfaces, making them suitable for spot-checks and sampling of various surfaces in a facility.

Microorganism Types:

Settle plates Vs Contact Plates :

• Settle Plates: Settle plates are particularly effective at capturing a wide range of airborne microorganisms, including bacteria, fungi, and even larger particles like dust and debris.
• Contact Plates: Contact plates are best suited for sampling microorganisms present on surfaces and may not be as effective in capturing airborne particles.

Analysis:

• Settle Plates: After the exposure period, settle plates are incubated to allow any captured microorganisms to grow into visible colonies on the agar surface. These colonies are then counted and identified.
• Contact Plates: Similar to settle plates, contact plates are also incubated to allow microbial growth. However, the analysis typically focuses on the type and quantity of microorganisms present on the sampled surface.

Sampling Area:

Settle plates Vs Contact Plates :

• Settle Plates: The effective sampling area for settle plates is the air within the vicinity of the plate. They provide a broader assessment of airborne contamination.
• Contact Plates: The sampling area for contact plates is the specific surface in direct contact with the plate. They offer a localized assessment of surface cleanliness.